log / 2026-11-09 / 4 min
The maths of a deductible
A deductible is a bet with known odds. Here is how to price it.
A deductible is the part of a repair you pay before your insurer pays the rest. Collision and comprehensive coverage each have one. Choosing it is one of the few insurance decisions you can work out on paper.
The trade
Moving from a $500 to a $1,000 deductible lowers your premium by some amount each year, call it S. In exchange, any claim costs you $500 more. So the question is how many claim-free years it takes for the savings to cover one claim: 500 divided by S. Deductible Break-Even runs that.
Reading the result
- Under three years: the higher deductible is usually the better bet for a driver with a clean record.
- Three to six years: a judgment call. Think about how often you have actually claimed.
- Over six years: the insurer is not paying you much to take the risk.
What the maths leaves out
Whether you could pay it. A $1,000 deductible you would have to put on a credit card is not a saving. The Insurance Information Institute makes the same point in its guide: Insurance Information Institute: Understanding Your Insurance Deductibles.
Two details people miss
- Collision and comprehensive deductibles are chosen separately. Comprehensive claims, such as glass and weather, are more frequent and smaller, so a lower deductible there can make sense.
- If the other driver was at fault, your insurer may recover your deductible from their insurer and refund it to you.
// references
// General information, not advice about your own policy.